By Damon DeBusk
Stringed instruments allowed to dry out will tend to shrink and may experience splitting along the wood grain of the body, bridge or fretboard. Under dry conditions, if not properly oiled, fretboard shrinkage may eventually result in “fret sprout” where the ends of the fret wires become exposed. The internet is full of photos showing dry and damaged stringed instruments. Too much or too little moisture may result in string buzz, warpage or inability to keep the instrument in tune. Many guitar repair sites report that up to 70% of their guitar repairs are related to dried-out instruments. Guitar manufacturers even add clauses into their warranties that exclude damage from temperature or humidity.
Current solutions include keeping an instrument, along with a moisture source, inside a case to contain the moisture. Multiple instruments require purchasing multiple humidifiers. Sponge humidifiers, typically in the $10-$20 range, require regular rewetting and most have no means for controlling the amount of moisture delivered to an instrument. Pouches offer a way to control the level of the relative humidity (RH). And some guitar players report spending as much as $75 to $100 annually on pouches for a single guitar.
Other options include humidity display cabinets and room, or whole-home, humidifiers as generally used in music stores. Some drawbacks to room humidifiers include daily refilling, mold and mildew formation, and a constant musty smell. Whole-home humidifiers may cost thousands of dollars to install, and humidity cabinet furniture may not be affordable to many musicians preferring to invest in instruments rather than furniture.
Musik Tent™ was developed to bridge the gap between current solutions – with the ability to last months between refills. It stores, displays and uniformly humidifies up to four full-size guitars or other wood Instruments. Musik Tent eliminates the need for cases, and its moisture source is not in direct contact with the instruments inside. The instruments are quickly and easily accessible, and accessories such as capos, tuners, and straps may remain affixed to the Instruments during storage. Musik Tent may be mounted to a wall, ceiling, door or placed in a closet for those not wanting their instruments displayed, taking up floor space, or exposed to visitors, pets, kids or sunlight. One option is to mount a Musik Tent on a wall, so the bottom of the enclosure touches the floor, thus allowing cases or traditional stands to be supported inside. Additionally, free-standing frames are available, the Jumbo version having a built-in, adjustable stand that can store 3 to 4 guitars and/or cases.
Putting these humidifiers to the test
I selected sponge soundhole humidifiers because they are commonly used, and initiated the testing during the driest period of the year in Pennsylvania. Sponge humidifiers are generally comprised of a section of perforated rubber tubing, about 12 inches in length, with an elongated sponge contained inside. On one end is a plug to hold the sponge in place. On the other end is a cap that prevents the device from falling inside the instrument when inserted into the soundhole through a separation in the strings. Sponge humidifiers are generally wetted by holding them under running water to absorb to their capacity, wringing out the excess water, and towel drying before each use.
Reluctantly, I drilled holes in one of my hard-shell plastic guitar cases, so I could feed hygrometer leads inside with probes placed at four key positions to observe the relative humidity variation inside the case. The goal was to allow the case to close tightly, without pinching the leads or leaving the case partially open during testing.
Beginning January 12, 2019, I placed an already humidified guitar into the prepared case and inserted a single wetted, sponge humidifier into the soundhole. I then placed hygrometer probes in the areas around the headstock, neck/body, soundhole, and on top of the body near the output jack. I latched the case shut and placed a fifth probe just outside the case to measure the surrounding ambient humidity.
The next day, the soundhole was reading 40% RH, while the other probes inside the case read about the same relative humidity as the room. I’d expected the soundhole value to be considerably higher, given the moisture content in a newly wetted sponge, and that the guitar was already humidified. To confirm the accuracy of the hygrometers, I performed a salt test and found they were reading a few percent higher than the expected 75% RH. I elected not to apply a bias since the difference was minimal. I returned the hygrometers and added a second wetted sponge humidifier.
Additionally, to compare two methods under the same ambient temperature and humidity, I set up a 2-guitar model Musik Tent, inserted a second guitar, and placed hygrometer probes at essentially the same four positions around the guitar, as done with the case.
Tracking results by percentages
Over the following days, I observed the performance of all the humidifiers, including during an outside temperature drop to 13 degrees F, where the home heater worked continuously to maintain ambient temperature at 68 deg F at night and 72 deg F during the day. The ambient humidity dropped as low as 19% RH during this period.
One week into the testing, the soundhole humidity inside the case reached 50% RH. By January 24, the ambient humidity increased to 31% RH. Even so, the soundhole humidity inside the case had declined to 47% RH. Musik Tent soundhole was measuring 49% RH, so I made a small adjustment of the filament to increase the humidity slightly. By the next morning, the Musik Tent sound hole humidity had increased to 50% RH.
A week later, Pennsylvania experienced another cold snap where the ambient humidity dropped to 17% before returning to 31% RH. These were not “normal” conditions, with the outside temperature reaching nearly 60 Deg F. The soundhole humidity inside the case had declined to 41% RH.
The case hadn’t been opened since inserting the 2nd sponge humidifier, but I suspected the sponges were dried out and moisture was being released from the instrument. As a reminder, the instruments used for these studies were already humidified. The Musik Tent continued to maintain a few percent variation in humidity over the entire instrument and had consumed little distilled water at this point in the study.
On February 7, the ambient humidity further increased to 33% RH, although the soundhole humidity inside the case remained at 41% RH. I elected to open the case for the first time since Jan 13th, removed the sponge humidifiers, and closed the lid. As suspected, both sponge humidifiers were dried out.
Observations of the case testing
It had taken nearly a week for the soundhole humidity to reach a peak of 50% RH, with 2 inserted sponge soundhole humidifiers, where humidity remained at peak for about two days before declining. The neck/body and output jack humidity inside the case tracked very closely together and were essentially identical. Headstock humidity inside the case tended to track somewhat with the ambient humidity highs. This may be indicating the case seal is less effective around the headstock, and/or moisture from the sponge humidifiers is being blocked from reaching the headstock. There may also be a sponge effect from the case liner that was not pre-humidified before the study.
Following the study, we learned from a major high-end guitar manufacturer that some wood cases may absorb twice as much, or more, moisture as the instrument. And that if allowed to dry out, cases may rob moisture from the guitar inside resulting in considerable damage. This was not a factor in this study due to me arbitrarily selecting a plastic guitar case.
Variation inside the case reached as high as 20% between the soundhole and headstock about a week into the study, following the peak in the soundhole humidity level.
After the case portion of the study in early February, the guitar from that study was moved to the Musik Tent. So, two instruments were humidified inside the Musik Tent through the remainder of the study that concluded at the end of July 2019 when the reservoir containing the distilled water was nearly dry.
Observations of the Musik Tent testing
The soundhole humidity took nearly one week to reach an initial peak of 50% RH, and slowly declined over 200 days of testing. The neck/body area was consistently the lowest recorded humidity value while the output of Jack humidity was consistently the highest recorded humidity value. I suspect this may be related to the variation of air density inside the enclosure – or variation of the probes. Headstock humidity inside the product tended to track somewhere between the neck/body and soundhole.
Musik Tent showed big-top performance
While the original intent of the study had been to monitor the effectiveness of various instrument humidification schemes for a normal winter in PA, the large variation in ambient humidity and outside temperature during this testing appeared to have little effect on the results. The exception being the headstock inside the case that seemed to be partially influenced by ambient conditions.
While sponge humidifiers stored in instrument cases may be adequate for maintaining the desired relative humidity greater than 45% inside the sound hole, there are several downsides with their use. The humidity inside the sound hole appears to take approximately one week to reach peak relative humidity, and then very quickly begins to decline. If the instrument owner forgets to rewet the sponge regularly, allowing the instrument to dry out each time between charging the sponge(s), it’s possible that the cycling up and down of the humidity could cause damage to the instrument over time.
Additionally, in this study we observed humidity variation across the instrument inside the case as high as 20% RH with the headstock that never got above 32% RH. The effect on the instrument of having low humidity around the headstock was not considered in this study. The results may be indicating a need to keep the case humidified even when not being used.
Musik Tent achieved an initial peak of 50% RH in about a week with adjustments to the filament, slowly declining to around 47% RH over 200 days of testing. This meant that Musik Tent lasted more than 6 months – on a single fill of distilled water, compared to sponge humidifiers lasting only a few weeks after being wetted. Humidity variation inside the Musik Tent remained nearly constant at 4% RH throughout the study, compared to as high as 20% RH for the two sponge humidifiers. Another bonus observed with Musik Tent was that the guitars stored inside tended to remain in tune during the duration of the study, with very little retuning needed.
After the initial cost of a Musik Tent Instrument Humidor of $110 to $150, the cost-of-ownership is around $1 to $2/month for distilled water and periodic filament replacements, making Musik Tent a cost-effective alternative with considerably better performance than sponge humidifiers.
To learn more about Musik Tent Humidifiers please visit: www.origineer.com
If you enjoyed this content please consider supporting us by becoming a Guitar Connoisseur Patron
You can also visit our Digital Downloads section to purchase a High Resolution Digital Ebook of any of our past issues.